I’ve finally decided to try and tackle the project, which I had put off for 2+ years. My fear has been that I couldn’t do the site justice, and no matter what I build on it, the content will offend certain people with different beliefs. I am not a Torah or Judaism expert, so I couldn’t contribute much to the site, and it’s not something I could just go out and hire writers.

I had a bit of an  epiphany  the other day, and I want to share how I plan to move forward in the next couple of weeks.

I plan to build a site that is very, very similar to I have found that many people visit because they have questions about the Torah, and at, they will be able to ask their questions.

To ensure that people know if answers are coming from legitimate sources, I plan to invite a diverse group of rabbis to become “ Rabbis.” Each will have his or her full profile listed and a special icon will designate the person’s title. This should help spur discussion and allow people to see who are experts and who may not be experts.

I plan to moderate the discussions to avoid anti-semitism or other negativity that is bound to come up. I will use a WordPress plugin to keep all questions in queue as pending review until I approve each.

I am currently generating a bit of revenue from the two affiliate links on the landing page, and I will create a few banners on the new site to also drive revenue.  I may implement a special WordPress plugin that links specific words to affiliate pages, but that will be down the road.

So… what are your thoughts on this plan? It’s taken me quite some time to move forward, but I think it’s a good idea. I’d love your feedback.

Elliot Silver
Elliot Silver
About The Author: Elliot Silver is an Internet entrepreneur and publisher of Elliot is also the founder and President of Top Notch Domains, LLC, a company that has closed eight figures in deals. Please read the Terms of Use page for additional information about the publisher, website comment policy, disclosures, and conflicts of interest. Reach out to Elliot: Twitter | Facebook | LinkedIn


  1. @Elliot,

    Figure out a way to blend it with an existing social-networking and/or dating site for people of the Jewish faith (I’m assuming these are out there) – just make sure those you affiliate with aren’t tacky, or it’ll ruin what you’re trying to accomplish. I like the idea of engaging Rabbis for the project – it lends immediate legitimacy.

    – TBC

  2. Inviting experts to contribute makes sense as it adds authority to the site. One challenge with any blog where readers comment or ask questions is administering / filtering out off-topic discussion and inflamatory language. Monetization might be a challenge. Who would you target for banner sales?

  3. Great ideas, Elliot.

    You obviously have a lot of neat things to implement, but in time, you might also consider a translation section to make the site the international source for all things Torah.

    And since you’ll have guest Rabbis, I would imagine many are likely to be multi-lingual in addition to English & Hebrew.

    Best wishes!

  4. “ rabbis” – seems misplaced to me – i might use a more generic term (eg, spiritual adviser) – you’re taking something very formal and serious (discussion of the torah) and incorporating a commercial spin – tread very lightly – just my 2 cents.

  5. A great idea. Maybe you could add other levels of expertise such as “ Maven” and/or “ “Mahof” etc. to label people w/o formal degrees that can add other details about judaism or torah. There are also many rabinical students who would participate in something like this. My cousins used to trade “rabbi’ trading cards I seem to remember.

  6. This one is going to be a challenge Elliot. I have seen similar projects run by both Chabad and Aish that I am sure you can learn from. The key I think will be the Rabbis that you can get for this project and the moderation is a must. I wish you much success and I will definitely be keeping an eye out on this one.

  7. Isn’t it fun when the small niche market of domaining suddenly expands to a worldwide readership? Exactly what domainers need to focus on. Looking forward to the completed site.

  8. @ Elliot
    “I plan to moderate the discussions to avoid anti-semitism”

    Yes, yes, yes.

    Agree with Shai, “the moderation is a must”

    This could take up more of your time than you’d like to devote to this project.

    I would also not allow any language other than English to be displayed. (So nothing slips by.)

  9. When I read the title “Building”, I immediately thought of a forum, a community for Jewish users to ask and answer questions. Glad your actual project isn’t much different. Good luck with your project, Elliot, I really like it.

  10. Great post..
    several ideas…

    Torahs are expensive for Jewish temples to buy….
    so you could put a contribute button/ people could help other congregations….

    Torahs have covers and ornaments. ecommerce for those artists/ craftspeople/

    Etsy for torahs kind of thing.

    lastly…Torahs are painstakingly hand written and crafted…
    webcam the calligraphers….interview them…
    that way every new Torah would have a story like a custom
    harley…(just joking …God…)..

    lastly….don’t forget a little humor…. place a few Mel Brooks easter eggs on the site…at least on Purim…(or Passover for that matter…)


  11. I hope I’m wrong, Elliot, but I see the (critically) necessary moderation duties quickly turning this into a full-time endeavor.

    There’s certainly nothing wrong with that if income weren’t a factor; but since you’re saying it is …

    Sadly; as we’ve seen time and time again; the Internet enables the tiny percentage of human animals of the world far-to-easy access to the eyes and minds of the huge majority of good-hearted human beings.

  12. With WordPress, all questions that show up will appear as pending review before going on site. I can then either publish or delete them at my convenience. I should only hope to get so much traffic that moderation becomes burdensome 🙂

  13. @ The Big Cheese
    I’ll mod for you in return for free ad space
    So would you moderate right after you have had your
    (3rd) Glass of Petite Syrah (as you said, your Daily Fav)
    to get into the divine spirit!

  14. You have a huge responsibility with a name like this, but developing relevant partnerships should be easy as pie. You won’t have any trouble finding people to write for, probably at no cost.

    No idea how to monetize the site without it coming off as tacky or making the whole concept feel as if it were “made for banners”. That’s going to be a real tightrope you have to walk, since it won’t take much in the way of crass commercialization on to inspire significant opposition.

    Sometimes, the right path is to first build something meaningful and relevant to people, then figure out how to monetize it later, once the people are on board. When you go into a site with monetization as the goal (whether you openly admit it or not), it impacts the trajectory of the entire project which in turn, may lead to suboptimal decisions.

    Build sites for people, not for ads. The ads will come once the people do. Sometimes, patience and a long soak is required before monetization should even be considered.

  15. Sounds like a solid development plan.
    100% agree with the partnership/advertising potential… Have a food/recipe section, dating, artwork as mentioned in a previous comment, other services, etc. Also, if there are ipad versions you could easily resell them I would think…
    Plus, don’t forget that controversy spurs comments and visitors so if you have a section that draws on that such as a comparison area of different religion’s perspectives and offer others opinions/blog entries it might be beneficial to traffic – would probably take a lot of mod work though…
    Good luck – great plan though so I’m sure you’ll implement well!

  16. Are you planning on making the website Kosher? 🙂 I mean in compliance with Sabbath observance? (no posts, moderation…).
    Your plan is 100% solid, and this is coming from my personal experience. As I mentioned before, I use Askmoses (dot) com all the time to find answers to my concerns. you might want to consider looking at it for ideas.

  17. @Elliot,

    Kind of thought you’d pass on my offer.

    You should give serious consideration to Adam’s idea about making the site “Kosher”, i.e., close down the forum on the Sabbath – it’s an AWESOME marketing angle that would likely get you loads of word-of-mouth, viral marketing within the Jewish faith…think about it.

    – TBC

  18. I didn’t not mean to close the website entirely on Sabbath (even if it could be a great idea). I meant by that, limiting your activity: posting, moderating, etc.. I’m sure none of the Rabbis will be online online at the time anyway.

  19. Have you done a keyword competition analysis yet?

    (Kinda weird to be ‘competing’ in that space, but it’s a reality, I guess.)

  20. @Uzoma – “Original” How is this original?

    “You won’t have any trouble finding people to write for, probably at no cost.”

    Why would any self-respecting Rabbi work for “free” on a commercial domainer site ?

    I think it’s far more complicated than this. There has to be an overall purpose. I don’t think “cleaning up misconception” is really a valid selling point. Maybe there will be some who do things for free, but I’d have to wonder why? What do they get back? Or do we believe that there’s this altruistic subject and therefore the contributions will be so also even though it’s a commercial venture?

    As a comment. The logo HAS to change. It looks like too giant nipples ready to get sucked on.

    “Milking Religion…” might work as a tag-line.

    That said, I wish you luck. I just think trying to develop in an area that you don’t understand is purely a recipe for failure and might actually lower the domain value. You’d be much better off either with minimal monetization or actually selling this to an organization that might profit from it properly knowing what they are doing.

    Where will you draw the line on discussions of Hacidic versus Modern Orthodox movements? I say YOU because you’re going to moderate these discussions?!??!?

  21. @ Adam

    I’m sure none of the Rabbis will be online online at the time anyway.

    Unless they discover online porno,

    then it’s Goya 24/7 🙂

  22. Not an area Im too familiar with really, though currently Im working setting up an online archive for a group of people with memories of darker times.
    This is potentially a huge project, with sensitive areas that need to be implemented with thought and observance. I think its great you left this until you felt you have time to do it justice. Also, the possibility of getting professional collaborative assistance (cyber-rabbis!) is what probably makes it viable.
    Im not convinced the idea of keeping it English is such a good plan, perhaps most forums would be, but it strikes me this one is an exception. Not so sure banning the ‘language of God’ ie Hebrew, is gonna go down so well on .

    Good luck and have fun building it!

  23. Funnily enough…and this is for THE BIG CHEESE

    Search for :

    It says:

    Did you mean Torah.TV?

    Just found that interesting. I guess it does redirect to which is a monetizing religion effort.

    I still think the Logo needs to be changed!

  24. Nice, that bad boy needs to finally be developed. My thoughts are:

    1) agree with the person above who said don’t focus on monetization until after you build a useful, full website that has targeted traffic. A sharp, clean Jewish Q&A site could definitely work, and will be so much more rewarding with more potential in the long run if it’s a nice and full website rather than a sandbox affiliate/banner-oriented site. The logo already looks awesome.

    Also, if the Rabbi-expert idea isn’t practical, then you can always just do a normal Q & A site with jews sharing their views/take on the questions.

    2) Negative on the dating … that is way to much to deal with, liability, not to mention JDate which is booming

    3) Like the recipe ideas, advertise cards and relevant treats for holidays, maybe contact a distributor of said goods, etc. (if the traffic warrants it)

    There’s is a ton you can do and it could be a fun project. Keep us updated.

  25. @Got jesus

    If the logo truly looks like two succulent nipples “ready to be sucked” to you, NOT EVEN FURNITURE IS SAFE AROUND YOU!
    You definitely need the LORD!

    The Logo is fine, Elliot. This guy is a pervert.

  26. Hi Elliot, Torah is a fundamental part of the life of millions all over the world. Yes, you can make a fortune out of, because of this fact. However, in my opinion there are some things in Judaism that should not be turned into a business. Torah site like this, is one of them. I think there is an ethical dimension here that you should consider. Turning a website about the most important pillar of Judiasim into a revenue generating website just seems to be wrong, somehow. I can’t believe I am the only person who feels this way. Just my gut reaction, Ray

Leave a Reply

Recent Posts Acquired by Owner of

In July, Rick Schwartz announced that he reached a deal to sell the domain name for seven figures. The announcement was made on...

Spaceship Doubles its DUM

At the end of July, I wrote about Spaceship surpassing 100,000 domain names under management (DUM). The registrar continues to grow, and its Founder...

You Can Now Hide Estimated Value at Dan

Last week, announced and deployed a feature I did not like. On the user control panel, Dan showed GoDaddy's Estimated Value for each... Buyer Comments on Acquisition

This afternoon, Axios reported the sale of the domain name. Kismet Group, an Australian private equity company, acquired the domain name to launch...

“We love to share success!”

If I see two friends or colleagues that could benefit from meeting over a shared interest or converging path, I am always on the...