A Seller Request I Reject

When buying a domain name from a person or company who previously used it, I am sometimes asked to not resell the domain name to a competitor. Typically, I am not willing to except this request. In fact, I recently lost out on an acquisition deal because I couldn’t honor that request in good faith.

For the most part, I am buying domain names as investments. The intent is to monetize the domain names as best as I can while I own them, with the ultimate goal of ultimately reselling them.

Most of my domain names are listed for sale on Afternic with BIN prices. I do not have any control over who buys the domain names I list for sale on Afternic or via any other platform. I also have limited control over the domain names I list for sale via Embrace.com because buyers regularly make offers in stealth mode.

I have found that many times the domain names I am interested in buying are so generic, it is unlikely to attract a competitor to the former owner. A brandable one word .com domain name can be used by any type of company. It is doubtful a competitor of the former owner will spend a premium to get its hand on a generic domain name, unless that generic name has something to explicitly do with that industry. Even so, I do not want to promise or agree contractually to never sell to a competitor.

Even if I were to agree not to sell to a competitor, most sellers would likely want that memorialized in the contract and ensure I keep that assurance in place to any subsequent buyers. Essentially, anyone who ever buys that domain name will have to agree not to sell it to a competitor of the original owner. That is difficult to enforce, especially if a domain name is sold many times. Since I would be the original person to agree to such a deal, if a competitor ever got ahold of the domain name, the original seller would come after me and I would be forced to spend money on legal fees to untangle the mess.

This type of request is not common, but it can be a deal killer for me.

Elliot Silver
Elliot Silver
About The Author: Elliot Silver is an Internet entrepreneur and publisher of DomainInvesting.com. Elliot is also the founder and President of Top Notch Domains, LLC, a company that has closed eight figures in deals. Please read the DomainInvesting.com Terms of Use page for additional information about the publisher, website comment policy, disclosures, and conflicts of interest. Reach out to Elliot: Twitter | Facebook | LinkedIn


  1. There are other platforms that list the names and IP address of the potential buyers when they sent in the inquires and not in stealth mode

  2. That would never be an acceptable term unless the domain was for a specific development project I was doing. Even then, unlikely it would be agreeable.

  3. “Most of my domain names are listed for sale on Afternic with BIN prices.”

    Is that how most of your sales occur?

    • No – just a small percentage. The majority are via inbound leads to the for sale landing page or outbound sales.

Leave a Reply

Recent Posts

Taking a Blog Break

I have been writing articles on my blog since 2007. I have been fortunate to have the advertising support of many domain industry companies...

Some Thoughts About 2023

As the year winds down, I have been thinking about what to expect for the upcoming year. I am hopeful that it will be...

How I Am Preparing for the New Year

Less than a week remains in 2022. This is generally a quiet week in terms of domain name sales, so I tend to spend...

Squadhelp Introduces AI Business Name Generator

Earlier this month when OpenAI's ChatGPT chatbot was trending, I discussed some of the ways artificial intelligence (AI) could be used for domain investing....

I Don’t Always Have to Win

I am a highly competitive person. Whether I am playing a tennis match against a friend or playing a board game with my family,...