Home Blog Page 1092

Is “Double Dipping” Acceptable?

I am interested in knowing your feedback about a topic I’ve discussed in private with a few people during the last few years.

“Double dipping” is where an intermediary (can be a broker or marketplace) takes a percentage commission from the buyer of a domain name as well as the seller, and each person believes he is the only entity paying the commission. Similarly, this can also mean the broker or intermediary is pocketing the difference between a buyer’s price and a seller’s offer, and taking a commission on top of this.

I want to share two hypothetical examples to illustrate what I mean.

  • A broker contacts me on behalf of a buyer and offers me $10,000 to sell ElliotsBlog.com to his client. I agree to the terms, which includes my paying a 15% commission. The broker also told the buyer he needs to pay a 10% commission for closing the deal, without mentioning that I am paying, too. Instead of making just $1,500 or $1,000 total on the buy or sell-side commission, the intermediary is actually making $2,500.
  • I list ElliotsBlog.com for sale in a newsletter or on an aftermarket site for $10,000. Later, I am informed that an offer of $8,000 was made, and I accept it. The intermediary tells the buyer that my price is firm, and he agrees to pay $10,000 to buy the name. The broker pays me $6,800 after taking my 15% commission from the supposed $8,000 sale and also keeps the $2,000 difference between what the buyer paid and what I thought the sales price was. In total, the “commission” was $3,200 instead of $1,500 on a $10,000 deal.

In both of these cases, the buyer and seller are willingly accepting a deal that’s presented to them, so it’s not entirely unacceptable since both parties agreed to the deals as presented. However, neither would likely be happy if they knew that the broker wasn’t presenting the full offer or was charging double commission.

There aren’t as many legal regulations on brokering domain names as there are with real estate, where this would likely be prohibited.

If the buyer and seller are both happy with the deal as presented to each, is there an issue with this happening? What are your thoughts on this type of thing?

Moniker is Now a Member of the SedoMLS Premium Partner Network

2

I know there are many domain investors that use Moniker as their registrar, and it just became easier to sell Moniker-registered domain names via Sedo using the SedoMLS Premium Partner Network. Sedo just sent an announcement to clients informing them that customers may now activate names in the Network.

A Moniker and Sedo partnership had previously been announced, but I guess the final integration for the Premium Partner Network just happened today. I think I will spend some time activating my Moniker-registered names when I have a chance.

I posted the email announcement below along with the SedoMLS Premium features.

We are getting in touch with an important service update to let you know that your registrar Moniker is now a member of the SedoMLS Premium Partner Network, which means that our customers can activate SedoMLS Premium for any domains that they have registered with Moniker.

SedoMLS Premium features include:

  • Exposure: Domains are visible within millions of searches on SedoMLS partners’ sites.
  • High Conversion: Buyers can purchase domains directly at partner sites.
  • Sell Now Assurance: We check Buy Now listings to ensure that sellers still own these domains.  
  • Fast Payout: We release your payments within one business day.  
  • Instant Transfers: Buyers get domains more quickly, with eligible partners.

Customers can activate SedoMLS Premium in the My Domains section of their Sedo account. Have a question about this product update, or about SedoMLS Premium? Contact Customer Care to Ask A Question now.

Go Daddy Rectifies Invalid Whois Issue on Moniker Transfers

After transferring several domain names from Moniker to Go Daddy recently, I noticed that the Whois lookup looked funky on these names, and after further investigation, I found that Godaddy was reporting a contacts error  inside my control panel. It probably wouldn’t have caused any problems for the domain names, but it’s not good to have incorrect Whois information.

A couple of days ago, I received a notice from Go Daddy’s Nick Fuller informing me that the issue has been resolved. When I posted the article, the company was in the process of getting its parsing updated on transferred Moniker domain names, and that process has been completed.

The company may still be working on the parsing script for transfers from other registrars (like Network Solutions), but it is something that is being fixed as we speak. If you find this error on transfers that are completed from now on, please post a comment here to let the company know. It will be helpful to know the losing registrar and transfer date.

Things I Look for in Expiring Domain Names

I’ve been buying and bidding on more and more expiring domain names at NameJet in the last couple of years. I wouldn’t say I am a big buyer, but I do spend quite a bit of time searching for good dropping domain names to buy, and I’ve had some success flipping auction purchases (never sold to a former owner though).

I want to share some of the things I consider when buying names on NameJet and Snapnames:

  • Previous owner
  • Development status
  • Inbound Links
  • GAKT information
  • Number of results for the keyword in Google
  • Potential TM issues
  • Age
  • Other TLD registrations and usage
  • Whether it’s a private sale

I weigh each of these factors differently, depending on the domain name, and quite a bit of my interest still boils down to a gut feel.

One thing I do is filter the names that have bids with an hour to go before the bidding deadline, and I analyze those based on gut feel. I figure I can check the analytics/stats during the auction, since as second or after bidder, I won’t be the leading bidder. Most of the time I place a bid on names of interest in that list and decide whether to be aggressive after the fact.

What do you look for when buying expiring/dropping domain names at auction?

Using a Domain Broker RFP

Not all domain brokers and brokerages were created equal. Some brokers will use a newsletter to sell a domain name, and others will personally pitch end users via email or phone. Some brokers have significant experience selling specific types of domain names, and others don’t specialize in a vertical. Different brokers charge different commission rates for different sales efforts.

There are many differences between the various brokers and brokerages in the domain industry.

When people have emailed me in the past to ask for advice about working with a domain broker, I’ve generally recommended that they issue a RFP (request for proposal) to their top 3 or 5 brokers and brokerages. The purpose of the RFP is to see how the broker will go about selling a domain name and how much it will cost you if the domain name is sold.

I am looking to sell CallCenters.com, and I am going to take  issue an informal RFP to the companies I intend to engage. I want to share the questions I plan to ask, so you can see how I set up a RFP. Feel free to recommend other questions or ask why I am asking something, and I will address it.

1) Have you sold similar domain names, and if so, what names and what were the sales prices?

2) If you are given the exclusive contract, what marketing activities will you undertake in order to sell the domain name (phone calls, press releases, emails, mailing list newsletter, placement on your website…etc)?

3) What is your valuation of this domain name and where would you price it?

4) What is your commission rate and exclusivity period?

Is WIPO “Advising” Complainants?

29

This is a post written by contributor,  Paul Raynor Keating. Paul is an attorney specializing in domain names and related matters. He lives and works in Barcelona, Spain.

I was recently surprised to read the following WIPO notice received by a friend of mine the other day:

“Dear Complainant,
Further to our Acknowledgement of Receipt of Complaint, as required by Paragraph 4(a) of the Rules for Uniform Domain Name Dispute Resolution Policy (the Rules) and Paragraph 5 of the WIPO Arbitration and Mediation Center (the Center) Supplemental Rules for Uniform Domain Name Dispute Resolution Policy (the Supplemental Rules), we have reviewed your Complaint to verify whether it satisfies the formal requirements of the Uniform Domain Name Dispute Resolution Policy (the Policy), the Rules and Supplemental Rules.

In accordance with Rules, Paragraph 4(b), you are hereby notified of the following formal deficiency with your Complaint:

(1) The text below section (C) of the Complaint, with the emboldened heading “Bad Faith in the Domain Name Use”, does not appear to describe why the domain name should be considered as having been registered and being used in bad faith.

Please note that paragraph 4(a)(iii) of the Policy and paragraph 3(b)(ix)(3) of the Rules require a complainant to describe why the domain name(s) should be considered as having been registered and being used in bad faith.”  (Emphasis in original).

Procedural requirements as the form of a complaint are specified in the UDRP and Supplemental Rules and compliance with matters of form are appropriate. Thus, for example, checking to verify that the name of the respondent comports with the WHOIS is a procedural matter because of the notice requirements in the UDRP. Other examples of form verification are the presence of a mutual jurisdiction selection and the required “verification”.

It is entirely inappropriate, however, for an ADR provider to conduct a substantive review of the complaint to verify that the complainant has included sufficient argument and evidence to sustain its burden of proof. There is no requirement in the UDRP or any of the Supplemental Rules stating that a complainant must provide argument and evidence in order to file a UDRP complaint. They only describe the substantive content needed to prevail. ADR providers are supposed to be neutral.

Notices such as the above effectively give the complainant a second bite at the apple because they are being advised to review and correct substantive issues pertaining to their burden of proof. They turn the ADR provider into an editor working for the benefit of the complainant. The proper course would be to refrain from any such apparent impropriety and let the panelist deal with the matter – the consequences of which must be reserved to the parties.

I question the propriety of the above notice for the simple reason that it evidences a substantive review of the complaint on the part of WIPO to correct a “deficiency” which would otherwise have led to a denial of the complaint.

Perhaps I shouldn’t be surprised. But I am continually disappointed at the ever expanding ways in which ADR providers assist complainants in the UDRP process. I have long objected to the constant stream of “reminders” sent to complainants about deadlines and the like, particularly those from NAF reminding complainants to correct complaints that have been rejected for filing. I have never once seen a “reminder” forwarded to a respondent. ADR providers must avoid the appearance of impropriety so as to protect the overall system from criticism and legal attack. ADR providers are supposed to be neutral. Matters of proof are the exclusive realm of panelists and WIPO is crossing the line.

The “deficiency” process is further marred by the way respondents are treated in the process. The domain is locked the minute the ADR provider receives a filing. The lock remains in place during the 5-day correction period. However, respondent is not permitted to see a copy of the complaint that had been submitted with the argument being that the UDRP has not “commenced”. My response is that the domain should then remain unlocked until the complaint is accepted for filing. The fact that the ADR provider maintains the lock and refuses to provide respondent with a copy of the “defective” complaint is merely an exercise to limit any possible advance notice to the respondent.