Home Blog Page 1083

Thank You EuroDNS, and Welcome Stevan Lieberman and Nokta Domains

I want to take a moment to thank EuroDNS for advertising on my blog for almost a year. The company continued to renew its banner advertisement monthly for quite some time, and I appreciate their supporting my blog.

I also want to thank two new advertisers on my website.

Stevan Lieberman is an attorney at Greenberg & Lieberman, a Washington, DC based law firm that primarily specializes in intellectual property. Lieberman is widely respected in the domain space.

For those of you who purchase descriptive domain names, you’ve likely seen Nokta Domains in many Whois lookups. Nokta owns a huge portfolio of fantastic domain names spanning many verticals. The company actively buys and sells domain names.

I welcome Nokta Domains and Stevan Lieberman, and I want to thank them for advertising. Without the support of companies within the domain name ecosystem, I wouldn’t be writing my blog, so I hope you support them, too!

Google Wins Huge UDRP

This morning, The National Arbitration Forum posted a UDRP decision that was decided in favor of the complainant, Google. The UDRP covered hundreds of domain names with the Google trademark in them. Some of the domain names that were registered by the respondent include:

  • googlebarack.com
  • googlemiamiheat.com
  • googleroyalbankofscotland.com
  • googleroyalbankofscotland.com
  • googlewesternunion.com
  • googlelarealestate.com

According to Google’s response in the UDRP filing, “Respondent has recently engaged in one of the most aggressive campaigns of domain name infringement that Complainant has encountered, having registered at least 750 domain names subject to this Complaint.” It appears that the domain names contained a Google trademark and either a search term like “real estate” or another trademark like “Western Union.”

The domain owner’s response discussed Google’s trademarks: “Respondent’s petitions to cancel two of the Complainant’s US trademark registrations for the GOOGLE mark, which were filed weeks after the initiation of the instant proceedings, ‘is an inappropriate attempt to subvert the due process provisions built into the UDRP process.‘”

The domain owner contended that Google has seemingly become a generic term: “The Complainant has been aware for some time that its mark is being used generically as at transitive verb meaning “to search the Internet”. Since “google” is now considered a generic term, the proper forum to decide the issue is the Trademark Trial and Appeal Board or the courts.”

The three panelists found in favor of Google, and all of the domain names have been ordered to be transferred to Google.

One interesting facet in this is that Google will own hundreds of domain names it arguably didn’t want to own but didn’t want someone else to own either. It will be interesting to see if they let these names drop or choose to renew them for thousands of dollars a year.

Juan Diego Calle Responds to Comments

41

There were a number of comments critical of  Juan Diego Calle in an article I posted this morning as well as an article posted by Rick Schwartz.  Although the video Rick and I shared was primarily about LeWeb’s move from LeWeb.net to LeWeb.CO, the founder of LeWeb referred to the owner of LeWeb.com as a “squatter,” despite his having registered the domain name before LeWeb.net existed (and he successfully defended the UDRP – well, not really “defended” since it was a win without filing a response).

In response to some of the critical comments, Calle posted an article on the .CO blog entitled “How I feel about domainers.” You can read the article for yourself and post comments there, but some of the takeaways from his article include:

  • Calle is a domain investor, and one of his other companies owns names like ParisHotels.com, NewYorkHotels.com, MiamiHotels.com…etc.
  • Cybersquatting makes the domain industry look very bad
  • There is a distinction between cybersquatting and domain investing

One issue I take with Calle’s article is the last paragraph: “if you’re a cybersquatter, or even a mass speculator, leveraging technology to register thousands of names, please do so in someone else’s backyard. ”

Some of the biggest companies in the domain investment business could be considered mass speculators. One of the most successful .CO investors stated that he  uses technology to buy domain names (“we have 150,000 names many of which a machine registered“).

I am bothered by cybersquatting as much as Calle because it does make us look bad to the general public and to people in the tech space. However, there is a big difference between cybersquatting on someone’s brand and speculating on descriptive domain names. I am sure Juan would be upset if someone filed a UDRP on one of his descriptive domain names and called him a cybersquatter simply because Juan wasn’t using it in the way that a complainant thought it should be used.

I still think the news of LeWeb switching to .CO is very big for the .CO Registry because of its audience. I do think the video backfired though.

** 5/14 Update **

Juan clarified his comments on leveraging technology to register domain names.

Video: Why LeWeb Moved to .CO

22

I want to share a video I was sent with entrepreneur Loic Le Meur of LeWeb and Juan Diego Calle of the .CO Registry. In the video, Le Meur announces LeWeb’s switch to .CO and discusses why the change was made from the .net extension where it previously resided.

If you’ve never heard of LeWeb before, it’s a “European Internet event, where 2500 entrepreneurs, leaders, investors, bloggers, journalists will gather together for 2 days in Paris. LeWeb brings together the most influential audience in the Internet ecosystem. Top industry entrepreneurs, executives, investors, senior press & bloggers gather for 2 days in Paris to focus on the key issues and opportunities in the web marketplace.”

Because of its wide reach, this is a pretty big announcement. Testimonials about the conference come from heavy hitters like Eric Schmidt and Sean Parker (Schmidt was the keynote speaker in 2011). This year, LeWeb will also be expanding to London in addition to its Paris conference.

One thing of interest is Le Meur’s discussion of LeWeb.com, as the company filed a UDRP for it in 2011 and lost. It’s a bit surprising that Le Meur called the owner a “squatter” since I believe that domain name was owned prior to LeWeb’s existence. As the panelist in the UDRP opined, ”  when a domain name is registered by the respondent before the complainant’s relied-upon trademark right is shown to have been first established (whether on a registered or unregistered basis), the registration of the domain name would not have been in bad faith“.

IDNX Records Monthly Decline in April

1

It appears that the domain market hot streak is in more of a holding pattern, at least according to Sedo’s IDNX. A report from Sedo  this morning announced that the IDNX domain price index recorded a 2.1% decline in April, following growth of more than 22% during the last six months.

Sedo reported that there are a couple of factors that may have led to this decline in April:

  • “Glimpse into the the wider economy suggests that people were spending less on domains during April, accounting in part for the fall in the total value of domain sales.”
  • “Another factor in April’s 2.1% decline was a small decrease in the number of sales. This is likely due to sellers’ reluctance to adjust asking prices for their domain listings based on decreased demand.”

Comparatively, the NASDAQ 100 index saw a 3.1% decline and Apple stock fell 2.5% (probably because I invested in it). Coincidentally, April was the strongest month of the year for me after recording a few large sales.  I operate on a very micro level though with some  anomalous  sales, so I wouldn’t necessarily think my performance is  indicative  of the overall market.

Hopefully this is just a temporary setback for the domain market.

Sedo’s full release is below:

Vanity TLDs in Google

I thought it would be interesting to see how many websites Google has indexed for a variety of “vanity” tlds. Although some of the tlds I searched include ccTLDs, I figure much of the usage is by people who are not using them for geotargeted local websites.

To get the results below, I did a Google search for “site:.tld” and the numbers are reported. Clearly there are far more results than domain names registered, so it’s likely that many of the results are for subdomains. It’s not scientific by any stretch, but it’s interesting to compare the number of indexed sites in Google.

  • .ME –  633,000,000 results
  • .TV –  588,000,000 results
  • .CO –  267,000,000 results
  • .MOBI –  245,000,000 results
  • .WS –  149,000,000 results
  • .NAME –  36,100,000 results
  • .TRAVEL –  22,800,000 results
  • .LY –  9,710,000 results
  • .XXX –  5,410,000 results