I have had the majority of my portfolio listed for sale via DAN.com around six months. During this time, I have done some testing of the different types of landing pages offered by DAN, which includes the longer term payment plan offering, the BIN page, and the BIN page with a Make Offer option.
Initially, I was not crazy about BIN + Make Offer landing page. My feeling has been that someone who sees the buy it now price with a make offer field will choose to make an offer. After all, the prospect can usually just buy it for the asking price if the seller rejects the offer – or possibly get a better price. With that said, I have sold several names for the BIN price without an offering being submitted, so it doesn’t always lead to an offer.
A point of frustration, though, is when a buyer believes their offer will be given full consideration only to learn that the seller is inflexible on the price. Afterall, most people expect to be able to negotiate when they see the buyer is willing to consider offers.
Case in point, I read a one star review of DAN which focuses on this very topic: