Home Blog Page 470

Daily Poll: Have UDRP Decisions Swung in Favor of Registrants?

0

Tim Davids suggested that I ask a poll question and I am also interested in seeing the results. Do you think UDRP decisions have swung more in favor of domain registrants lately? For the sake of the polling, let’s assume Tim isn’t asking about domain names involving fairly obvious trademarks (ie “Realtor”) but rather valuable generic (dictionary and phrases) and acronym domain names.

I was able to find some data for UDRP decisions in the last several years, and I will share that along with some thoughts later on today. For now, I would like to know if you feel UDRP decisions have swung in favor of domain registrants lately.


Anything.com Defends Sante.com in UDRP with RDNH Finding

2

Anything.com successfully defended its Sante.com domain name in a UDRP that was defended by Jason Schaeffer of ESQWire.com. The UDRP was filed by an entity called LOGOCOS Naturkosmetik AG at the Czech Arbitration Court (CAC). The UDRP resulted in a finding of Reverse Domain Name Hijacking (RDNH).

Anything.com owns a large portfolio of keyword domain names, including domain names like Medicine.com, Manager.com, Favor.com, Public.com, and a large portfolio of valuable 3 letter .com domain names. Anything’s portfolio is easily one of the top ten domain portfolios based on the quality of its generic domain names.

The word “sante” means “health” in French, so it would seem perfectly fine for a domain investor to own Sante.com. The complainant in this UDRP owns the Sante.de ccTLD domain name, and it is clear why it would want the better .com domain name. Apparently, it opted to file a UDRP instead of buying the domain name from the registrant.

There is some good language for domain investors in the UDRP decision. I highlighted a few excerpts with additional commentary:

Daily Poll: Do You Have a Domain Portfolio Website?

46

If you own a large portfolio of domain names, having a domain portfolio website can be a good way to sell domain names. If a prospective buyer can’t afford to buy a specific domain name, or if someone stumbles upon the website while seeking out a domain name, it can provide a good opportunity to offer other domain names for sale to a prospective buyer. In addition, it can look more professional to operate a portfolio website.

For someone with a smaller domain portfolio, having a portfolio website may not be as useful. A prospect looking for a cooking domain name, for example, may not be able to find a similar domain name in a person’s small portfolio, and thus, it would be less useful to operate a portfolio website.

There are at least a couple of companies that offer portfolio websites (like Efty, a DomainInvesting.com advertiser). For those more technically inclined, it may not be too difficult to build a portfolio website using WordPress or other content management system. I have done this to some extent with Embrace.com, although it is not a traditional portfolio management website.

Today’s daily poll asks if you have a domain portfolio website. You are welcome to share what you use and/or what you like or dislike about it.


Prince Estate Files Suit Over Prince.com Domain Name

8

According to a news report in the New Jersey Law Journal (found via Law.com), the estate of the late musician known as Prince filed a lawsuit to try and get the Prince.com domain name. According to the article, “The suit claims that the company’s ownership of the domain violates §43(d) of the Lanham Act because it represents a bad-faith intent to profit from association with the artist, who died at age 57 in 2016.”

The lawsuit is targeting Domain Capital (an advertiser on DomainInvesting.com), a company that offers various financing options for domain owners. Here’s what seems to have been the impetus for the estate of Prince to file the lawsuit, according to the Law.com article:

“According to the complaint, Domain Capital represented to the estate in a May 9, 2018, letter that it owns www.prince.com pursuant to a lease-back financing agreement with an unnamed third party. Domain Capital said in the letter that it leases the domain back to its previous owner so that party’s identity may be shielded from the public, the complaint states.”

I visited Prince.com this morning, and the domain name did not resolve. The Law.com article states that “Domain Capital has not used it in connection with any offering of goods or services, according to the plaintiffs.”

In August of 2010, DNJournal reported that the Prince.com domain name was sold for $235,000 via Media Options. That sale ended up being the 35th largest publicly reported domain name sale of 2010. From my vantage point, Prince.com is so valuable because of the generic nature of it, as evidenced by the thousands of trademarks in the USPTO containing the word “prince” and the likely tens of thousands of companies and brands with “Prince” in their name.

I am more familiar with the UDRP process than a Lanham Act lawsuit, but Prince.com seems like a generic domain name to me. I am familiar with two large companies called Prince, including Prince (the tennis and sports company) and Prince (the pasta company). According to Wikipedia, there are also quite a few other companies called Prince as well as people with that last name and/or nickname. Obviously, “prince” is also a meaningful word – for instance Prince William and Prince Harry are two famous princes.

The Prince.com domain name has been the subject of prior legal disputes. In what I believe could be called a landmark case, Prince Sports Group, Inc. tried to wrest control of Prince.com from a British company called Prince plc but was unsuccessful. Here’s what was

Whoisology Acquired by WhoisXML API

I noticed that the Whoisology.com domain name changed registrants to the Escrow.com escrow account. I reached out to Whoisology co-founder Ryan McKegney, and he confirmed that his company sold the Whoisology business to WhoisXML API earlier this year. “We were looking to focus on DomainAgents and since WhoisXML was already a Whoisology partner with deep expertise in the whois data and internet security field, we felt they were a very natural fit who could do interesting things with the site,” he told me.

The transaction price was not disclosed to me by either party, but the entire Whoisology business was sold.

Whoisology is a business that provides a number of services related to domain name Whois records. Users can perform reverse Whois searches via Whoisology to link various domain names to a particular registrant. The business also has archived historical Whois records as well. Whoisology can be helpful to

Daily Poll: Do You Own Pure .com Geodomains?

17

I have owned quite a few geographic domain names. I have sold many of them over the years, and I still have several.

I buy good .com geodomain names when I see them for sale at fair prices, and they are generally acquired as investments rather than for a development opportunity. I am not opposed to developing geographic domain names, but I have sold the names I previously developed (with the exception of LakeWinnipesaukee.com), and I don’t really have the desire to build out any new websites right now or in the foreseeable future.

For the sake of this poll, when I refer to “pure .com geodomains” I mean exact match city, state, province, region, lake, country…etc. .com domain names (not citystate.com domain names though). I don’t mean geo+keyword domain names nor do I mean something like citystate.com. I would imagine the vast majority of investors own domain names like geo+keyword or citystate.com. There’s nothing wrong with these kinds of domain names, but I am interested in seeing how many people own exact match geographic .com domain names. Examples could be Boston.com, GrandCanyon.com, Quebec.com, ColoradoRiver.com…etc.

Participate in the poll below and feel free to share your favorite pure .com geodomain name if you would like.