My Reply to “GoDaddy Says It’s Worth $X”

Last week, I wrote about a prospective buyer whose offer was made based on a GoDaddy appraisal. After the opening offer was made, I think I was able to make a pretty salient rebuttal to his offer. Although he ended up increasing his offer to a more reasonable number, we were unable to reach a deal. I won’t say the appraisal is what doomed the deal, but it did set the discussion off on a bad note for me.

Sometimes a low appraisal isn’t the issue. There have been other times when someone cited an appraisal that was more than I believe the domain name is worth.

Earlier this year, a person replied to an offer I made by telling me GoDaddy said his company’s domain name was worth substantially more than what I offered to buy it. He was referring to the free, algorithm-based GoDaddy Appraisal tool, which did indeed report that the domain name is worth more than my offer. I typically deal with buyers telling me my price is much higher than the automated appraisals, but I want to share how I replied to the domain registrant in this case:

“If I could sell my domain names for close to what GoDaddy says they are worth I could retire comfortably. I think it is in GoDaddy’s best interest to give high values so people continue to pay them to renew their domain names. For an example of how inflated their appraisals can be, GoDaddy says [] is worth more than $800 and that name is not even registered!”

I think it was very powerful to show that an unregistered domain name is appraised at $800 when his long registered domain name is valued by the same tool at 10x that figure. The example I used had part of his domain name in it, and the example domain name makes no sense. If he believes his company’s domain name is really worth $X because of the GoDaddy tool, he can see how unrealistic it is because a domain name that doesn’t even make sense is reportedly worth more than $800. Had I wanted to illustrate this without using a word from his domain name, I could have found an even more valuable unregistered domain name as an example.

There are times when I think GoDaddy’s Appraisal tool can be helpful. When someone offers me $500 for a domain name that I have priced at $12,000 and appraises at $20,000, I can send them the appraisal. On the flip side, it is frustrating when a counterparty uses the appraisal tool as a negotiating tactic. When that happens, it is my job to share why I think the tool is unreliable.

Elliot Silver
Elliot Silver
About The Author: Elliot Silver is an Internet entrepreneur and publisher of Elliot is also the founder and President of Top Notch Domains, LLC, a company that has closed eight figures in deals. Please read the Terms of Use page for additional information about the publisher, website comment policy, disclosures, and conflicts of interest. Reach out to Elliot: Twitter | Facebook | LinkedIn


  1. When someone quotes a bogus price based on GoDaddy’s free Appraisal tool. Another technique that might work is to send them the links of some of the other free tools to show them how even the various appraisal tools disagree with each other.

    Here is an example (

    GoDaddy – $2,085 – $24.70
    Estibot – less than $100

    All 3 of those are pretty far off from the true value.

    • It looks like NW just pulls numbers out of the air. Which is no different than the other appraisal sites. Its “ok” with me.

      I entered a few domains.
      I would sell each one appraised at the price NW quoted.

      I would send potential buyers to the NW website but it requires too much effort for a potential buyer. They should have a one appraisal a day as a guest. They don’t get a new sign-up but they do receive traffic which would raise its seo ranking. And, then goog would add the service to their first page.

      Congratulations to the owner of NW. Nice job.

Leave a Reply

Recent Posts

Nick Huber: “drop a little coin” for a Premium Domain Name

I do not know Nick Huber, but I see he has a large following on Twitter and frequently offers advice to startup founders and...

Trademarkia Hiring Lead Developer for Domain Registrar Integration

Trademarkia is a website I use occasionally to perform trademark-related searches. This morning, I noticed a job listing the company posted on LinkedIn that...

SquadHelp Ultra Premium Marketplace Goes Live

🎉 It's here! The Ultra-Premium Marketplace is live We've partnered with @HilcoDigital to curate an incredible collection of domains. More additions coming soon! 🌟 Check it...

ROTD Auction Web3 Domain Names

According to a press release I received a moment ago, Right of the Dot is auctioning "Web3" domain names in partnership with Unstoppable Domains.... Dispute Gives Guidance on Common One Word Domains

The latest #UDRP Digest (Vol 3.37) is out now! Read about some interesting cases including,, and more, with commentary from @dnattorney...