An Issue I Face with Make Offer on

For most of my domain names listed for sale on, I have a Buy It Now (BIN) price, a Lease to Own (LTO) option, and a Make Offer option. IThe majority of prospects choose the Make Offer option and submit an offer that is close to the minimum permitted. The next most popular option selected on my names, I would guess, is the LTO option.

In the last month, I’ve come across an issue two separate times on Prospective buyers made offers that were accepted and then stated they want to pay over time. In one case, the prospect accepted a counter-offer, and in the second case, I accepted the initial offer. Both prospects then asked the agent handling the deal if they can use a payment plan to buy the domain name.

In the first case, I told that I would permit the buyer to pay with a payment plan. The ROI was high enough that I could justify the payment plan. Despite the agent’s efforts to re-connect with the prospect to discuss the length of the payment plan, the person disappeared and did not buy the domain name.

In the second case, I told that I would not permit the buyer to use a payment plan. I accepted the offer on the assumption payment in full would be made. If the buyer would not be able to do that, the deal can be canceled and he can choose a payment plan based on the original asking price. The deal was agreed to on Saturday evening, and so far, has not heard back from the prospective buyer.

What I will likely do is remove the Make Offer option on domain names I believe are priced fairly. On the other names, instead of presenting a counter-offer right away after rejecting an initial offer, I will ask “if I reduce the price to $X, can you pay for the domain name by Y date?” At this point, they can ask about a payment plan or confirm when they will submit payment in full.

Elliot Silver
Elliot Silver
About The Author: Elliot Silver is an Internet entrepreneur and publisher of Elliot is also the founder and President of Top Notch Domains, LLC, a company that has closed eight figures in deals. Please read the Terms of Use page for additional information about the publisher, website comment policy, disclosures, and conflicts of interest. Reach out to Elliot: Twitter | Facebook | LinkedIn

Leave a Reply

Recent Posts UDRP Decision is Upsetting

Last night, I saw that WIPO had posted an update regarding the UDRP. is a domain name registered in 1996, and I...

CEO of Shares Domain Name Acquisition Learnings

Jordan Fried is the owner of some exceptional domain names. A few of the domain names he owns include,, and This...

Taking a Blog Break

I have been writing articles on my blog since 2007. I have been fortunate to have the advertising support of many domain industry companies...

Some Thoughts About 2023

As the year winds down, I have been thinking about what to expect for the upcoming year. I am hopeful that it will be...

How I Am Preparing for the New Year

Less than a week remains in 2022. This is generally a quiet week in terms of domain name sales, so I tend to spend...