1919.com Lost in UDRP Decision

A UDRP was filed against the high value 1919.com domain name at the National Arbitration Forum (NAF). The complainant in the UDRP is a company called 1919, LLC, and the domain registrant did not respond to the UDRP. The UDRP was decided by a single panelist, The Honourable Neil Anthony Brown QC, and the UDRP was decided in favor of the complainant.

At a quick glance, I was surprised to see the complainant prevail, despite the fact that the registrant did not file a response to the proceeding. I don’t recall many other UDRP cases involving short numeric domain names that were decided in favor of a complainant.

After reading the decision, there was a key finding from the panelist that likely weighed heavily on the decision:

“Complainant registered the <1919.com> domain name domain name in the year 2001. In or about the year 2004, an employee of Complainant, namely Alan Wong, wrongfully caused the domain name to be registered in his own name as registrant. On or about June 21, 2011 Respondent wrongfully registered the domain name by way of transfer from Alan Wong who had no authority to transfer the domain name to Respondent.”

When I read the dispute, I wondered why it took nearly 9 years for the complainant to file a UDRP. If one of my domain names went missing, I would go after it right away. The Rights or Legitimate Interests section of the decision seemed to offer an explanation about the delay. “(c) Respondent has caused the disputed domain name to resolve to Complainant’s own website;”

From my reading of the decision, it would appear that the 1919.com domain name was transferred without authorization, and the complainant’s website subsequently continued to resolve at 1919.com. At some point in time, the 1919 company realized the domain name was no longer registered to the company, and the company filed a UDRP to remedy this. Because the company’s branding and marks matched the 1919 in the domain name, and because the domain registrant did not respond to refute any of the complainant’s argument, the panelist ruled in favor of the registrant.

I don’t like seeing an investment grade domain name like this being transferred to a complainant via UDRP, but assuming the evidence provided by the complainant is factual, I think the panelist made the right call here.

Elliot Silver
Elliot Silver
About The Author: Elliot Silver is an Internet entrepreneur and publisher of DomainInvesting.com. Elliot is also the founder and President of Top Notch Domains, LLC, a company that has closed eight figures in deals. Please read the DomainInvesting.com Terms of Use page for additional information about the publisher, website comment policy, disclosures, and conflicts of interest. Reach out to Elliot: Twitter | Facebook | LinkedIn

3 COMMENTS

  1. Complainant is responsible for its own employee’s actions.
    If the Complainant can’t monitor its own assets, that is it’s own fault.
    Had there been a response stating that, the claim should have failed.
    There must be another “good” reason there was no Response

  2. It took almost ten years for the Complainant to realize he had no control over the registration? It sounds like the “employee of the Complainant” (Alan Wong) was his webmaster and registered the name. 🙂

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Recent Posts

Escrow.com No Longer Supporting Payments To/From China and Israel

4
Escrow.com maintains a list of countries / regions from which it does not support payments. Buyers and sellers in these regions can not receive...

Atom.com Shares Non .com Sales Distribution

3
I have spent more money on non-.com domain names this year than ever before. My perspective is that startups are using them as less...

MAD Comment from NTIA About “Wholesalers”

4
Andrew Allemann wrote about the US National Telecommunications and Information Administration (NTIA) statement about the .com registry extension agreed upon with Verisign. As a...

Beware When Using AI for Domain Name Descriptions

6
Artificial Intelligence can be a time saver. For domain investors, it can make it easier and quicker to create marketing copy to help promote...

Atom.com Promoting Black Friday Sale

0
Atom.com is promoting a Black Friday sale with a prominent header banner on its home page. Atom CEO Darpan Munjal shared some insight and...