Changing from a .org to .com Ends in a Tribunal

Michael Bilde sent me an interesting Daily Mail article that had to do with a company’s domain name change. From what I understand, an executive at “an organic sex aid company” called Yes Yes Yes allegedly decided to change the company’s domain name from the .org to the .com, and it did not go well. One of the founders of the company, who was opposed to making this change, was not happy when it was allegedly changed without approval.

Here’s an excerpt from the Daily Mail article:

“A senior executive at an organic sex aid company called ‘Yes Yes Yes’ was sacked from his £60,000 a year job after he changed the firm’s website address from .org to .com, a tribunal heard.

Head of marketing and sales Ciaran Arstall changed the address without his boss’s permission, as he believed it would boost sales for the company.

Yes Yes Yes, which specialises in making natural lubricants, was founded by two women who chose to use ‘.org’ in its domain name because they found it ‘amusing’.”

From what I can tell, it looks like the company had been using YesYesYes.org for its website. Whois History records from DomainTools show the company’s founder was also the registrant of the matching .com domain name since at least 2013. It was private for a couple of years before that. According to NameBio, YesYesYes.com sold on NameJet for $800 in November of 2011.

For what it’s worth, I looked at Archive.org and I do not see any record of the .com domain name being used beyond forwarding to the .org domain name so I can’t see what happened or when it happened.

I can understand why a marketing executive thought it would be wise to switch to the .com domain name for a business like this, but I can also understand why a company founder would not want to change a domain name after being in business for so long. At best, a url change can cause issues for a short period of time as things get updated. At worst, it can cause a major problem if things aren’t done entirely correctly. Even when things go well, there can be unforeseen issues. It reminds me a bit of the Nuts.com story from several years ago.

It looks like the company is now forwarding YesYesYes.com to its website on YesYesYes.org.

Elliot Silver
Elliot Silver
About The Author: Elliot Silver is an Internet entrepreneur and publisher of DomainInvesting.com. Elliot is also the founder and President of Top Notch Domains, LLC, a company that has closed eight figures in deals. Please read the DomainInvesting.com Terms of Use page for additional information about the publisher, website comment policy, disclosures, and conflicts of interest. Reach out to Elliot: Twitter | Facebook | LinkedIn

7 COMMENTS

  1. Interesting story. I’ve seen plenty of cases like this where someone just decides to move (migrate) to another domain name. If it’s not done right, it can be a disaster for SEO but also you’d lose sales potentially, and maybe even email if it’s not done right.

  2. I think the bigger issue is that changing a company’s domain name is a huge thing, so to do it without getting approval from the boss/owner seems like a huge problem. It is not just about what is best for traffic, it is that the owner chose the name themselves and liked the sound of .org better. Aside from the org___ r-rated pun I assume they find humor in, .org gives the products some research/medical/non-prodfit implications as compared to .com which comes off as commercial.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Recent Posts

GoDaddy DBS Broker Tom McCarthy Explains His Role

0
GoDaddy has two distinct brokerage teams that work exclusively on behalf of buyers or sellers. The Afternic team represents sellers who have listings on...

How Much Overlap on AI Domain Name Creation?

1
I sold a two word .com domain name for $4,999 via Afternic last night. The domain name consists of a noun and a verb,...

Atom Pay Offers $10 Transaction Fee Through 2025

0
Atom.com introduced one of the better Black Friday deals I've seen offered. The platform is allowing customers to transact with its Atom Pay service...

GoDaddy’s Paul Nicks Retires

3
Paul Nicks is a longtime GoDaddy employee of 18+ years, has announced his retirement from the company. Paul previously served as President of the...

Outbound Sales? Look for a Trade Organization

1
I don't think successful outbound domain name sales is easy. In fact, it can be pretty demoralizing depending on the response to your outbound...